A celebrity date with Hannah is auctioned off at a fundraiser and when the bidding war boils down to a tie, auctioneer Donny Osmond (as himself) suggests that Hannah accommodate both bidders which lands her on a double date with Johnny (Corbin Bleu) and Rico! Meanwhile, Roxy has lied to her former classmate Clarice (guest star Sheryl Lee Ralph) about being married to Robby in order to avoid feeling embarrassed at their class reunion.